The short answer
- A home battery earns the most. Across 15 battery programs with published pay, a 13.5 kWh battery earns $1,800 to $11,205 over ten years. Thermostats earn $210 to $955, and heat pump water heaters $130 to $1,300.
- Location sets the pay more than the device does. The same battery can earn six times as much in one state as in another, because each utility or grid operator values peak power differently.
- These are gross program payments, not net profit. They exclude equipment cost, installation and any share an aggregator keeps.
- Most home programs today are demand response. This calculator adds them up device by device. Fleets dispatched continuously into wholesale markets are modeled in the Orchestrated VPP Calculator.
What each device can earn in a VPP
Ten-year gross program pay for one device, from the lowest- to the highest-paying program we track
Swipe to see the full chart →
How the VPP calculator estimates earnings
Most battery programs pay for the average power a battery delivers during events, measured in kilowatts (kW). The calculator works that out from three inputs: the battery’s continuous power rating, the energy enrolled, and the length of each event. Power is limited by whichever runs out first.
Yearly pay = rate per kW × event power × (1 − yearly capacity fade) × (1 − events skipped)
Worked example: ConnectedSolutions in Massachusetts. A Tesla Powerwall 3 stores 13.5 kWh and delivers 11.5 kW. With 80% enrolled, 10.8 kWh is available for a three-hour event, or 3.6 kW. The program pays $275 per kW each summer, so the first year earns about $990. With 2% capacity fade a year, ten years add up to about $9,055 in gross pay. Thermostat, water heater and EV programs mostly pay flat amounts, so the calculator uses each program’s published upfront and yearly payments.
From demand response to orchestrated VPPs
Home programs sit on a spectrum. At one end, demand response calls devices a few times a season and pays each one separately. At the other, an orchestrated VPP dispatches batteries, EVs, thermostats and water heaters together, every day, and is paid on the fleet’s metered output. As more homes combine devices, value that one device cannot earn alone, such as discharging a battery charged by midday solar, starts to show up in the economics.
VPP Economics models the full spectrum with three tools: this calculator for today’s device programs, the Orchestrated VPP Calculator for wholesale-market fleets in NYISO, CAISO and ERCOT, and the VPP Program Designer for utilities writing new program rules. Compare the three.
Utility deep dives
For a closer look at one territory, each deep dive covers what the programs pay, paybacks, financing and where the utility’s VPP is heading. All utilities and programs.
Ameren Illinois
Batteries, EVs, thermostats and hourly pricing: rebate versus performance pay, paybacks and the coming VPP.
Read the deep dive →IL · residentialComEd
The $300/kWh battery rebate, scheduled-dispatch VPP, Time-of-Day versus Hourly Pricing, and owning a battery versus hosting a Base Power one.
Read the deep dive →NY · residentialCon Edison
BYOB battery pay, NYSERDA incentives, time-of-use versus SmartCharge, paybacks and NYC siting limits.
Read the deep dive →CO/MN · residentialXcel Energy
Renewable Battery Connect, the Colorado aggregator VPP, Minnesota’s storage incentive and time-varying rates, with a capital stack.
Read the deep dive →CA · residentialPG&E
Solar Billing Plan, E-ELEC versus EV2-A, ELRP, the ending DSGS program and the SAVE and SHARE pilots, with a capital stack.
Read the deep dive →CA · residentialSouthern California Edison
SCE versus community choice aggregators, Solar Billing Plan battery value, device pay and the BOLT whole-home study, with paybacks.
Read the deep dive →CT/MA/NH · residentialEversource
Energy Storage Solutions performance pay, ConnectedSolutions and ConnectedSolutions+, New Hampshire’s upfront incentive and the 0% HEAT Loan, with a capital stack.
Read the deep dive →MA · residentialMass Save
How Mass Save and the utilities split the work, ConnectedSolutions pay as efficiency money, device value and when solar charging pays.
Read the deep dive →MA/NY · residentialNational Grid
ConnectedSolutions, ConnectedSolutions+ rebates, BackupBattery+, NYSERDA incentives and the upstate VTOU rate, with a capital stack and paybacks.
Read the deep dive →OR · residentialPortland General Electric
The Smart Battery pilot, Peak Time Rebates, Time of Day pricing and Energy Trust of Oregon incentives, with a capital stack and paybacks.
Read the deep dive →WA · residentialPuget Sound Energy
Flex programs for thermostats, water heaters, EVs and batteries, Schedule 327 time-of-use savings for a flexible home, and the battery rate trade-off.
Read the deep dive →NC/SC · residentialDuke Energy Carolinas
Winter-morning peaks, PowerPair and Battery Control pay, time-of-use battery value, device credits and the 2027 net metering cliff.
Read the deep dive →VA · residentialDominion Energy Virginia
A 450 MW VPP pilot set by law, the world’s largest data center market, PJM capacity at its cap, device pay and battery paybacks.
Read the deep dive →TX · residentialAustin Energy
A city-owned utility inside ERCOT: Power Partner pay, 4CP value, braiding with ERCOT, Base batteries and a three-device case study.
Read the deep dive →NY · residentialNYSEG and RG&E
Two Avangrid utilities compared, whether a home battery can double dip with NYISO, and a ten-year cash test for a thermostat, EV charger and battery.
Read the deep dive →HI · residentialHawaiian Electric
One buyer on five island grids: export credits versus retail rates, BYOD Plus battery pay, water heater credits and a ten-year battery cash test.
Read the deep dive →MI · residentialConsumers Energy
A regulator pushing VPPs before the battery program exists: Summer Rate spread, Peak Time Rewards, thermostat pay and a ten-year battery test.
Read the deep dive →AZ · residentialArizona Public Service
Three clocks and one battery: the R-3 demand window, Storage Rewards events, a falling solar export credit and a ten-year battery test.
Read the deep dive →MO · residentialAmeren Missouri
Where the rate choice is the program: Smart Saver’s 5.3-times peak spread, Peak Time Savings for thermostats and EVs, and a battery test.
Read the deep dive →Frequently asked questions
How much can a home battery earn in a VPP?
In the 15 battery programs with published pay that we track, a 13.5 kWh battery earns about $1,800 to $11,205 over ten years in gross program payments. Programs that pay per kilowatt delivered, such as ConnectedSolutions in Massachusetts at $275 per kW each summer, sit at the top; flat sign-up rebates sit at the bottom. These figures exclude the battery’s cost and any aggregator share, so they are gross payments, not net profit.
Do I need solar to join a virtual power plant?
Usually not. Most battery, thermostat, water heater and EV programs accept homes without solar. A few programs only enroll batteries paired with rooftop solar, such as San Diego Community Power’s Solar Battery Savings and LUMA’s Customer Battery Energy Sharing in Puerto Rico. Add a solar inverter in the calculator to see which of those open up.
What is the difference between demand response and an orchestrated VPP?
Demand response sends a one-way signal a few times a season and pays per device or per event. An orchestrated virtual power plant dispatches a fleet continuously as one resource, measures it as a whole and often sells into a wholesale market. This calculator covers the first, which is how most homes join today. The Orchestrated VPP Calculator models fleets in NYISO, CAISO and ERCOT, and the VPP Program Designer models program rules still being written.
Why does a thermostat earn so much less than a battery?
A thermostat delivers about 0.5 to 1 kW for a few hours by shifting cooling or heating, and most programs pay it a flat amount. A battery delivers several kilowatts on command and is often paid per kW. Per kilowatt delivered, the gap is smaller, which is what the calculator’s “What each kilowatt earns” chart shows.
Are VPP payments taxable?
Treatment depends on the program and on the household’s tax situation. Bill credits and upfront rebates are often handled differently from cash payments. This calculator does not include taxes; a tax adviser can confirm how a specific payment is treated.
How accurate is this VPP calculator?
It is a planning estimate built from each program’s published terms, checked October 1, 2026. Real payments settle on measured performance against a baseline, and programs change rates, event counts and budgets from year to year. See Measurement & Verification for how results are measured.