Utility program deep dive · Massachusetts and upstate New York

National Grid C&I battery, demand charge and VPP economics

How Daily Dispatch, ConnectedSolutions+, CSRP, Auto-DLM, NYSERDA retail incentives and National Grid demand charges stack up for a business battery.

VPP Economics has no affiliation with, sponsorship from, or endorsement by any utility, aggregator, platform, or device maker named here.

The short answer

  • National Grid business batteries earn mostly from programs, not demand charges. Massachusetts G-3 distribution demand is $10.61 per kW-month, because transmission is billed per kWh (National Grid), against $33.95 on Eversource’s Massachusetts G-2 rate. Upstate SC-3 is $15.62 (National Grid).
  • In Massachusetts, Daily Dispatch does the heavy lifting. It pays $200 per kW each summer, locked for five years, and measures a battery by its own discharge with no baseline (ConnectedSolutions program materials). Our central case pays back in about 6.1 years with the federal credit.
  • In New York, the money is upfront and local. NYSERDA’s retail incentive is $175 per kWh in the current Rest of State block (NYSERDA via Central Hudson), about $70k on our battery. Auto-DLM pays $110 to $335 per kW-year under five-year contracts in six constrained locations (National Grid); systemwide CSRP pays far less.
  • Stacking needs care, depending on M&V methodology. New York’s load-relief programs measure against a customer baseline from interval-meter data (National Grid), so a battery that already shaves every afternoon shows less event reduction. Massachusetts Daily Dispatch does not have that problem for batteries.
$200per kW, MA Daily Dispatch
$10.61per kW-month, MA G-3 demand
$175per kWh, NYSERDA retail
$110–$335per kW-year, NY Auto-DLM

What each National Grid program is

Utility demand response

Daily Dispatch, Massachusetts

Up to $200 per kW for 30–60 summer events of 2–3 hours, with day-ahead notice (National Grid). Enrollment is through curtailment service providers such as CPower, Enel X and Voltus. Battery pay is capped at 150% of site peak load (NuWatt).

Utility demand response

Targeted Dispatch and small batteries

Targeted Dispatch pays $35 per kW plus a $10 weekend bonus for up to 8 events, measured against a 10-day baseline (program materials). Batteries under 50 kW use the $275 residential program (program materials).

Targeted VPP pilot

ConnectedSolutions+ for business

In Bridgewater, Targeted Dispatch rises to $80 per kW through March 2030 (National Grid).

Utility load relief

CSRP and DLRP, New York

CSRP pays $2.75 per kW-month in reservation plus $0.18 per kWh in planned events; DLRP pays $5 per kW-month in designated areas only (National Grid).

Location contracts

Term-DLM and Auto-DLM

Term-DLM is bid for three years, 4–8 p.m. weekdays, 2–10 calls a year. Auto-DLM pays fixed prices of $110–$335 per kW-year for five years in six locations, with up to 53 calls a year historically (National Grid).

State upfront incentive

NYSERDA Retail Storage

Per-kWh incentives for systems up to 5 MW that offset demand charges, join demand response or earn the Value Stack (NYSERDA). The full rate applies to the first four hours of duration (NYSERDA via Central Hudson).

Value per kW of flexible capacity

Value per kW-year by source

What one kW of reliable reduction or event delivery is worth a year at a National Grid business site.

Swipe to see the full chart →

$0$50$100$150$200$250$300$350Auto-DLM, Mexico5-year contract, one location$335G-3 transmission peakoptional, $21.91 per kW-month$263Daily DispatchMassachusetts, per summer$200Auto-DLM, Granby5-year contract, one location$195SC-3 demand, New York$15.62 per kW-month × 12$187G-2 demand, Massachusetts$15.24 per kW-month × 12$183G-3 demand, Massachusetts$10.61 per kW-month × 12$127Auto-DLM, West Adams5-year contract, one location$110CS+ Targeted, BridgewaterMassachusetts, per summer$80Targeted DispatchMassachusetts, + $10 weekend$45CSRP, New Yorkreservation + 7 events$19
Demand charges from National Grid Massachusetts and National Grid New York. Daily and Targeted Dispatch from program materials; CS+ from National Grid; CSRP from National Grid, with 7 four-hour planned events assumed; Auto-DLM from the 2026 RFP. The G-3 transmission value assumes the battery covers every monthly peak hour.

The strongest values are location-bound. Auto-DLM pays most where local feeders are overloaded, and those contracts come with event counts that differ widely by site. Massachusetts Daily Dispatch is the strongest stream available everywhere in the territory.

G-3 customers can opt into a transmission demand charge of $21.91 per kW-month set at the coincident peak instead of paying transmission per kWh (National Grid). A battery that reliably covers that hour could save far more than the distribution demand charge, but the election only pays if the site can hit every monthly peak.

The capital stack

Ten-year capital stack

Incentives plus 10 years of avoided costs and program pay as a share of installed cost plus 10 years of maintenance. Past the dashed line, the package more than covers its cost.

Swipe to see the full chart →

0%50%100%150%200%New York, Auto-DLM + NYSERDAno daily shaving124% · $316k vs $255kMassachusetts, G-3 + Daily Dispatchdemand + events142% · $361k vs $255kMassachusetts, Daily Dispatch onlyno demand savings107% · $272k vs $255kNew York, SC-3 + CSRP + NYSERDAdemand + events106% · $271k vs $255kNew York, SC-3 + NYSERDAdemand only99% · $252k vs $255kMassachusetts, G-3 demand onlyno events63% · $161k vs $255kCovers full costNYSERDA incentiveFederal creditDemand charge savingsConnectedSolutions payNew York program pay
Illustrative, undiscounted. 100 kW / 400 kWh at $600 per kWh, below New York’s 2026 behind-the-meter average of $638 (NY DPS); $15 per kW-year maintenance. Federal credit at 30%, subject to construction-start and sourcing rules (Sidley); in New York we apply it to cost after NYSERDA, which is conservative. 70 kW off the monthly peak. Auto-DLM at the $195 Granby price, renewed after five years. Energy savings and Clean Peak certificates are not counted.

Massachusetts Daily Dispatch alone covers more than the full cost, at about 107%. Demand savings add a smaller layer than at Eversource. In New York, NYSERDA and the federal credit cover about 47% before any operating value; whether the rest comes from demand charges or a local Auto-DLM contract depends on where the site sits.

We do not stack Auto-DLM with daily demand shaving. Both draw on the same afternoon discharge, and a customer baseline built from shaved days would shrink the measured relief.

Simple payback

Years to repay net cost from avoided costs and program pay, net of maintenance. Bars are capped at 25 years.

Swipe to see the full chart →

0 yr5 yr10 yr15 yr20 yr25 yrNew York, Auto-DLM + NYSERDA$195 per kW-year location6.6 yrMassachusetts, G-3 + Daily Dispatchwith 30% credit6.1 yrMassachusetts, Daily Dispatch onlywith 30% credit9.1 yrNew York, SC-3 + CSRP + NYSERDAwith credit on net cost8.8 yrNew York, SC-3 + NYSERDAdemand only10.2 yrMassachusetts, G-3 demand onlywith 30% credit22.7 yr
Same assumptions as the capital stack.

Assets and combinations

+
Battery only

Events first, peaks second

A four-hour battery covers 2–3 hour Massachusetts events and 4-hour New York calls at full power.

+
Solar + storage

SMART 3.0 and the Value Stack

In Massachusetts, the SMART 3.0 storage adder applies only to solar projects larger than 25 kW (Mass.gov). In New York, retail storage can also earn the Value Stack (NYSERDA).

Curtailable load

Baseline-measured

Load curtailment earns the same programs but is measured against a 10-day baseline in Massachusetts (program materials) and a customer baseline in New York (National Grid).

+
Fleet chargers

EV demand-charge relief

Massachusetts G-2 and G-3 EV pricing cuts the demand charge to $0 for sites below a 5% load factor through June 2033 (National Grid).

Financing and ownership

Own, borrow or buy a battery service

A 100 kW / 400 kWh battery at an upstate New York SC-3 site with demand shaving and CSRP.

Swipe to see the full chart →

OWN IT OUTRIGHTCash−$240k installedday one+$70k NYSERDA incentive$175 per kWh, at operation+$51k federal credit30% of net cost, at tax filing+$13k a yeardemand charge savings+$2k a yearCSRP pay−$2k a yearmaintenance10-year net cash$16kSite keeps every stream$BORROW THE NET COSTLoan=$0 down; incentives pay principalborrows $119k−$17k a year for 10 years8% interest+$13k a year, netsame savings and pay as cash−$54k of interestover the loan term10-year net cash−$38kCash-flow testTHIRD-PARTY OWNERShared savings=$0 capitaldeveloper owns the battery+$2k a yeara guaranteed 15% of demand savings=Developer keeps NYSERDA and CSRPand the federal credit=Needs about 29% lower costor a larger site, for an 8% return=15-year contractdeveloper carries upkeep and risk10-year net cash$20kPositive cash, if offeredCumulative cash to the site, years 0–10−$150k−$100k−$50k$0k$50kyr 0yr 2yr 4yr 6yr 8yr 10Shared savingsdeveloper owns the batteryCashowns the batteryLoanowns the batteryCash pays $119k net on day one
Illustrative, undiscounted. NYSERDA paid at commercial operation through the contractor (NYSERDA via Central Hudson). Loan at 8% over 10 years on cost after incentives. The battery service assumes a guaranteed 15% share of savings over a 15-year contract, an illustrative floor; at the modeled cost the developer would earn less than 8%, so a deal like this needs a lower cost or a larger site. The first 10 years are shown.

The developer’s side

The site’s line above is only half of the deal. The developer pays the full $240k, carries maintenance, insurance and performance risk, and prices all of it into the contract to earn a return on its capital (Morgan Lewis). Third-party storage contracts usually run 15 years or more (Peak Power), and lenders treat 15- to 20-year terms as financeable (Illinois Power Agency). The chart below values each deal from the developer’s side.

What the developer earns

Present value of what the developer receives, as a share of what it spends, by contract terms.

Swipe to see the full chart →

0%50%100%150%25% to the site, 10 yearsa short contract80% · $207k vs $259k25% to the site, 15 yearssame split, longer term81% · $223k vs $275k25% to the site, 20 yearswith augmentation in year 1184% · $234k vs $278k15% to the site at $171k15 years; installed cost 29% lower100% · $199k vs $198kCovers full costFederal credit, soldDepreciation tax valueNYSERDA incentiveCSRP payDeveloper share of demand savings
Illustrative. Present value at an 8% after-tax return with a 27% combined tax rate; past the dashed line the developer earns at least 8%. Federal credit sold at 92 cents per dollar; storage still qualifies (Plante Moran). First-year depreciation on cost less upfront incentives and half the credit, which needs tax appetite (Ferrius Energy). Costs include maintenance plus 1% of installed cost a year for insurance and asset management. Savings held flat, with rate increases offsetting battery fade; the 20-year case adds a 10% augmentation in year 11.

Upstate New York falls short even with NYSERDA paying $70k upfront. CSRP adds only about $2k a year, and about $13k a year of demand savings cannot give the developer 8% and leave any for the site. At the modeled cost, a developer cannot earn 8% and still leave the site a share of demand savings. Battery-service offers are not priced the other way around, as a fee on top of handing over the savings: shared-savings providers promote a guaranteed share from day one (Gridwealth Electric), and Peak Power’s projects in Westchester, New York, split bill savings and market revenue with the building owner (NYSERDA case study). A deal that cannot fund a share is usually not offered at all. A guaranteed 15% share would need an installed cost about 29% lower, near $171k, or a larger site where cost per kWh falls; providers such as Peak Power focus on facilities with more than 1 MW of load (Peak Power’s overview). The battery-service line above shows that 15% share. Location also changes this: in a high-priced Auto-DLM area such as Mexico, New York, at $335 per kW-year, a 100 kW contract would add about $34k a year (National Grid), enough to support a real shared-savings split.

Additional Finance Options and Considerations

Own

Upfront money does most of the work

Net cost about $119k after NYSERDA and the credit, repaid from about $13k a year.

Loan

Tight cash flow

Payments of about $17k a year compare with about $13k of annual value, so a loan works only if demand savings hold.

Battery service

Capital-free, if it pencils

At upstate SC-3 demand charges and today’s modeled cost, a developer cannot fund a share of savings. A lower installed cost, a larger site or a high-priced Auto-DLM location can turn it into true shared savings.

Massachusetts

Rate lock supports debt

The five-year Daily Dispatch rate lock (program materials) gives lenders a contracted revenue line for the first five years.

What ifs

Clean Peak certificates

Massachusetts upside

Recent long-term contracts cleared at $20.40–$36.40 per certificate, under a $65 cap (Clean Peak Market Outlook); DOER changed storage multipliers in 2026 (Mass.gov).

Auto-DLM location

Price spread of three times

At Mexico’s $335 per kW-year, a 100 kW contract is worth $34k a year; at West Adams’ $110, $11k (National Grid).

NYSERDA blocks

Rates decline as blocks fill

The next Rest of State block is $150 per kWh (NYSERDA via Central Hudson), $10k less on our battery.

Federal credit

Construction-start deadlines

Losing the credit adds about $72k to the Massachusetts net cost.

G-3 transmission election

Coincident-peak value

If a site elects the $21.91 coincident-peak charge and the battery covers it every month, 100 kW would avoid about $26k a year, before the change in per-kWh transmission.

Non-wires alternatives

Local RFPs

National Grid awarded 7 bids from 3 vendors in its 2026 Massachusetts non-wires RFPs (National Grid).

Compare: National Grid residential, Eversource C&I for the higher-demand-charge Massachusetts utility, and Con Edison C&I for downstate New York.

Method and caveats

An independent, hypothetical analysis for business owners, facility managers, program designers, developers and other readers in National Grid’s Massachusetts and upstate New York service areas. Terms checked October 27, 2026.

Assumptions: 100 kW / 400 kWh battery at $600 per kWh; $15 per kW-year maintenance; 70 kW off the monthly peak on G-3 or SC-3 secondary service; full 100 kW delivered across events; Daily Dispatch at $200 for 10 summers; CSRP at $2.75 reservation for five months plus seven 4-hour planned events; NYSERDA at $175 per kWh. Demand charges are distribution only.

Taxes, energy and supply savings, and Clean Peak certificates are excluded. Figures are illustrative avoided costs and gross payments before financing, degradation and augmentation. Gross payments are not net profit.

VPP Economics has no affiliation with, sponsorship from, or endorsement by National Grid, NYSERDA, Mass Save, any curtailment service provider or any company named here.

Keep going